Anime Tier List 2023: Ranking The Best Anime Of The Year

Hey anime lovers! It's that time of year again where we dive deep into the best anime that 2023 had to offer and sort them into a definitive tier list. Get ready for some hot takes, potential upsets, and a whole lot of anime goodness. Whether you're a seasoned otaku or just getting into the world of anime, this list will help you discover some amazing shows you might have missed. We'll be ranking anime based on factors like story, animation, characters, soundtrack, and overall impact. So, grab your snacks, settle in, and let's get started!

What is an Anime Tier List?

Before we jump into the rankings, let's quickly explain what an anime tier list is all about. Basically, it's a way of categorizing different anime series into different levels of quality, usually represented by letters like S, A, B, C, and D (or sometimes F). The S tier is reserved for the absolute cream of the crop, the anime that are considered masterpieces. The A tier is for anime that are fantastic and highly enjoyable, while the B tier includes anime that are good but might have some flaws. The C tier is for anime that are okay or average, and the D tier is for anime that are generally not recommended. Creating a tier list is subjective, of course, and everyone's list will be a little different, but it's a fun way to discuss and debate the merits of different anime.

How We Ranked the Anime

Our ranking process was pretty comprehensive. First, we watched a ton of anime released in 2023. This included everything from highly anticipated sequels to brand new original series. Then, we evaluated each anime based on several key criteria. Story is a big one – does the anime have a compelling plot, interesting themes, and satisfying character arcs? Animation quality is also crucial; we looked for anime with fluid animation, detailed character designs, and stunning visuals. The characters themselves are also important; we considered how well-developed, relatable, and memorable the characters were. And of course, we paid attention to the soundtrack, which can make or break an anime. Finally, we considered the overall impact of the anime – did it leave a lasting impression? Did it break new ground or offer a unique perspective? After carefully considering all these factors, we placed each anime into its respective tier.

S Tier: The Absolute Best Anime of 2023

These are the anime that truly stood out in 2023. They represent the pinnacle of anime storytelling, animation, and character development. If you haven't seen these yet, add them to your watchlist immediately!

1. Attack on Titan: The Final Season Part 3

Guys, did Attack on Titan stick the landing or what? This final installment was an emotional rollercoaster from start to finish, delivering shocking twists, heartbreaking sacrifices, and a conclusion that sparked countless debates. The animation was top-notch, the soundtrack was epic, and the characters were pushed to their absolute limits. Whether you loved or hated the ending, there's no denying that Attack on Titan is a masterpiece of modern anime. The way the story built up over the years, the complex themes it tackled, and the sheer scale of the conflict all contributed to its legendary status. This is anime at its finest, and Attack on Titan: The Final Season Part 3 earns its place in the S tier.

2. Vinland Saga Season 2

Vinland Saga continued to impress with its thoughtful exploration of violence, revenge, and redemption. Thorfinn's journey of self-discovery was both inspiring and heartbreaking, and the supporting characters were equally compelling. The animation was gorgeous, the soundtrack was haunting, and the overall atmosphere was incredibly immersive. Season 2 took a different approach than the first, focusing more on character development and philosophical themes rather than action-packed battles. This change of pace paid off, as Vinland Saga Season 2 proved to be a deeply moving and unforgettable anime experience. Its themes of pacifism and finding meaning in life resonate deeply, making it a must-watch for anyone who appreciates mature and nuanced storytelling.

A Tier: Fantastic Anime That You Shouldn't Miss

These anime are amazing and offer a high level of entertainment. While they might not be perfect, they're definitely worth watching.

1. Demon Slayer: Swordsmith Village Arc

The Demon Slayer craze continued with the Swordsmith Village Arc, delivering more stunning animation, intense action, and lovable characters. Tanjiro's journey to become a powerful demon slayer remains as captivating as ever, and the new characters introduced in this arc were a welcome addition. While the story might not be as groundbreaking as some other anime, the sheer spectacle of Demon Slayer is undeniable. The fight scenes are visually breathtaking, the character designs are iconic, and the overall production value is through the roof. If you're looking for a thrilling and visually stunning anime experience, Demon Slayer: Swordsmith Village Arc is a must-watch.

2. Bocchi the Rock!

Bocchi the Rock! was a surprise hit of 2023, capturing the hearts of viewers with its relatable protagonist, charming humor, and catchy music. The story of a socially anxious guitarist trying to find her place in a band was both heartwarming and hilarious. The animation style was unique and expressive, perfectly capturing the quirky personalities of the characters. Bocchi the Rock! is a feel-good anime that will leave you smiling from ear to ear. Its portrayal of social anxiety is both accurate and sympathetic, and the show's message of overcoming your fears and pursuing your dreams is truly inspiring. This is a must-watch for anyone who loves music, comedy, or just a good, heartwarming story.

B Tier: Good Anime with Some Flaws

These anime are enjoyable but might have some noticeable flaws that hold them back from being truly great.

1. My Hero Academia Season 6

My Hero Academia continued its run with Season 6, delivering more superhero action, emotional moments, and character development. However, some viewers felt that the season was a bit uneven, with some arcs being stronger than others. Despite its flaws, My Hero Academia remains a popular and beloved anime series. The world-building is fantastic, the characters are memorable, and the fight scenes are always exciting. Season 6 might not be the best season of My Hero Academia, but it's still a worthwhile watch for fans of the series. The stakes continue to rise, and the characters face increasingly difficult challenges, making for a compelling and engaging viewing experience.

2. Spy x Family Season 1 Part 2

Spy x Family continued to charm audiences with its unique blend of espionage, comedy, and family dynamics. However, some viewers felt that the second part of Season 1 wasn't as strong as the first, with the story becoming a bit repetitive at times. Despite its flaws, Spy x Family remains a highly entertaining and enjoyable anime series. The characters are lovable, the animation is stylish, and the humor is always on point. Spy x Family Season 1 Part 2 is a fun and lighthearted watch that will leave you feeling good. The dynamic between the Forger family is endlessly entertaining, and the show's unique premise makes it stand out from other anime.

C Tier: Okay Anime That Are Just Average

These anime are okay but don't really stand out from the crowd. They might be worth watching if you're bored, but don't expect anything amazing.

1. Edens Zero Season 2

Edens Zero continued its spacefaring adventure with Season 2, but failed to really capture the magic of the first season. The story felt a bit rushed, and the characters weren't as well-developed as they could have been. Despite its flaws, Edens Zero still has some redeeming qualities. The animation is decent, the action scenes are entertaining, and the overall premise is interesting. However, there are better anime out there, so only watch this if you're a die-hard fan of the series or have nothing else to watch.

2. Arknights: Perish in Frost

Arknights: Perish in Frost is an adaptation of the popular mobile game, but it didn't quite live up to the hype. The story was confusing, the characters were underdeveloped, and the animation was inconsistent. While the anime might appeal to fans of the game, it's not a very good adaptation and is unlikely to win over new viewers. There are better anime based on mobile games out there, so skip this one unless you're already a fan.

D Tier: Anime That Are Not Recommended

These anime are generally not recommended. They might have some redeeming qualities, but overall, they're just not worth your time.

1. Berserk: The Golden Age Arc - Memorial Edition

While the Berserk franchise is legendary, this memorial edition of the Golden Age Arc was a disappointment. The animation was subpar, the story felt rushed, and it didn't do justice to the source material. If you want to experience Berserk, read the manga or watch the original anime adaptation instead.

2. Junji Ito Maniac: Japanese Tales of the Macabre

While Junji Ito is a master of horror manga, this anime adaptation failed to capture the atmosphere and terror of his original works. The animation was stiff, the stories felt disjointed, and it lacked the unsettling visuals that make Ito's manga so effective. If you're a fan of horror anime, there are much better options out there.

Final Thoughts

And there you have it – our anime tier list for 2023! Remember, this is just our opinion, and your own list might look completely different. The most important thing is to watch what you enjoy and have fun with it. There were so many great anime that came out in 2023, and we're already looking forward to what 2024 has in store. What were your favorite anime of 2023? Let us know in the comments below!